Reading an offer beyond the base number
In banking the bonus is a large share of pay, and it is the part an offer letter is least specific about. Read everything around the base before you compare two offers.
Offers for the same title can match on base and still describe very different jobs. Letters are often vaguest on the terms that move total pay the most: whether the first bonus is guaranteed, how deferred awards vest and when you are next up for promotion. Ask for the documents the letter refers to, such as the bonus plan and the deferred compensation plan, since they govern most of these terms.
In the letter
Title and level
Banks sometimes bring a lateral in at a lower title, or at the same title with a later promotion date, especially when the move changes product or coverage group. A step down at the start can add a year to your path to the next title. Find out which applies and when you are next eligible for promotion.
First-year bonus
Ask about your first bonus in separate parts: whether you are eligible for one, whether there is a guaranteed minimum, whether it is prorated for the months you work and how much is discretionary. A stub bonus for a partial year is often a point of negotiation. Bonus plans commonly require you to be employed, and not serving notice, on the payment date, so read that condition in both banks' documents.
What you leave behind
List unvested deferred compensation and any unpaid bonus at your current bank. A bank that buys out deferred pay usually asks for statements of your unvested awards, and it may replace them with new deferred awards on a similar schedule in place of cash. Ask which form the buyout takes and when it vests.
Restrictions
Read the notice periods, non-solicitation terms and any limits on joining a competitor, in your current documents and in the new ones. Some banks ask senior bankers to serve their notice on paid leave, often called garden leave. A long notice period pushes back your start date, which can change whether you qualify for a first bonus, how much it is and when it is paid.
A side-by-side for two offers
Copy these rows into your own sheet, with a column for each offer and one for your current seat, over the same 12 months. Count a buyout once, against what it replaces. Leave a discretionary bonus blank until someone gives you a basis for a number.
- BaseThe figure, and the date it next changes1
- BonusEligibility, any guaranteed minimum, proration, the discretionary share and the conditions on the payment date2
- BuyoutWhat replaces forfeited deferred pay and unpaid bonus, in cash or in new awards, and its vesting3
- ForfeitedUnvested deferred pay and bonus you lose by leaving your current bank4
- TitleYour level on day one, and the date of the next promotion decision5
- NoticeYour current notice period, any garden leave and any restriction on the new role6
Outside the letter
The group
A group with a central staffer spreads live deals across its bankers, while a group where senior bankers staff their own deals can leave a newcomer waiting for a first mandate. Ask which model the group uses and how recent laterals into it have fared.
The hours
Ask a banker at your level how the last live deal ran: the weekends it took and when the team signed off on the final drafts. A specific deal gets you a truer answer than a question about a typical week.
For the questions to put to the group, see questions to run on a group before you move.
Consider your next move without tipping your hand.
Request access and set a mandate. You hear from Suited only when a seat matches it.
Request access