Reading an offer beyond the base number
At firms on a lockstep scale, the base salary is the line in an offer you could have predicted. Read the rest before you compare two offers.
Two offers on the same salary scale can describe very different jobs. Offer letters often leave out the hours the bonus depends on, how your class year is reviewed and the conditions the offer rests on, such as the conflicts check. Read each letter line by line and ask about anything it leaves out.
In the letter
Class year
The class year the firm credits you with sets your salary step at lockstep firms, and it often sets your bonus and your partnership timeline as well. Firms usually credit a judicial clerkship. A move from a smaller firm or into a new practice area can mean a lower class year than your years out of law school.
Ask how the firm decided your class year and whether it is reviewed after your first year. Reduced credit affects your pay and your promotion timing unless the firm adjusts it later.
Year-end bonus
Many firms tie the year-end bonus to a billable-hours requirement, and some prorate both the bonus and the requirement for a lateral who joins mid-year. Ask which applies to you in your first year. If the firm has paid special bonuses in recent years, ask whether laterals who joined mid-year received them.
Sign-on bonus
Most sign-on bonuses are repaid in full or in part if you leave within a set period. Ask for the amount, when it is paid and the repayment terms, and read the repayment terms as closely as the amount.
Start date and notice
Agree a start date with the new firm, and check your current firm's notice expectations in your agreement or its policies. Plan handovers for live matters before you give notice, and hold your notice until the new firm's conflicts check has cleared.
What you leave behind
A move also has a cost at your current firm. Count it before you compare offers.
- If you leave before your current firm pays its year-end bonus, you will usually lose it. Most firms pay it only to associates employed on the payment date.
- If you received a sign-on bonus when you joined your current firm and are still inside its repayment period, you may owe some of it back.
If the new firm offers a sign-on bonus, ask whether it is meant to cover these. Count a replacement payment once, against the loss it replaces.
Outside the letter
Hours
Ask what associates in the group billed last year, since the firm-wide target can differ from the group's own average. The same salary at more hours is a lower rate. For example, an associate who bills 2,400 hours earns about 17% less per hour than one who bills 2,000 hours on the same salary.
Title and track
Associate, counsel and staff attorney are different jobs with different paths. Some firms bring senior laterals in as counsel, with a partnership review later. Ask whether the role sits on the partnership track, and if it does not, what the role leads to.
The team
Ask who you will work for and how long recent laterals into the group have stayed. Questions to run on a firm before you lateral covers the rest.
A side-by-side for two offers
Copy these rows into your own sheet, with a column for each offer and one for your current firm. Any line you cannot fill is a question for the recruiting team before you sign.
- Class yearThe year credited, whether a clerkship counted and whether it is reviewed after your first year1
- SalaryThe step for that class year, and when it next rises2
- BonusFirst-year eligibility, the hours required and whether either is prorated3
- Sign-onThe amount, the payment date and the repayment terms4
- Left behindThe bonus and any repayments you would forfeit at your current firm5
- HoursWhat associates in the group billed last year6
- TrackPartnership track, the usual timeline and recent promotions in the group7
However you arrived, the next step is yours.
If a firm has invited you, reply in your inbox. If not, set a mandate and Suited will contact you only when a role matches it. In the app you stay anonymous until you ask to be introduced to a specific firm.
Request access